Wednesday, September 11, 2013

7-9. Force of Nature.

Two alien scientists deliver a dire warning.
THE PLOT

The Fleming, a Federation medical transport, has disappeared in the Hekaras Corridor. The corridor is the only safe path to travel through this region of space, which is characterized by intense tetryon fields. The Fleming isn't the only ship to experience issues. During the search, the Enterprise encounters a Ferengi vessel whose warp drive is offline and whose systems are crippled.

After Picard assists with repairs, DaiMon Prak (Lee Arenberg), the Ferengi captain, admits that they observed the Fleming traveling through the corridor and provides Picard with the ship's heading. But the Enterprise arrives too late. All that remains of the Fleming is debris.

Just then, the Enterprise is struck by a verteron pulse, taking the ship's warp drive and shields offline... at which point Hekaran scientists Rabal (Michael Corbett) and Serova (Margaret Reed) beam onto the ship with a potentially devastating revelation!


CHARACTERS

Capt. Picard: Though he is not pleased at the tactics of the Hekaran scientists, their claims are serious enough that he immediately agrees to let Data review their findings. He states that he considers it part of his job to keep an open mind, even when he's annoyed. When the rift opens near the end of the episode, complicating the ship's rescue mission, there are two obvious options - both of them bad. He tells his officers that he wants them to find him a third option, and trusts Geordi and Data to do just that.

Data: Has allowed his cat, Spot, such a degree of free reign that Geordi finds the cat unmanageable and "out of control." We see that whatever difficulties Data may face in training Spot, the cat has certainly trained Data, who feeds and plays with the animal on cue. In the "A" plot, it is Data who figures out how to complete the rescue mission without using warp engines in the rift, calculating what to do to the exact second.

Geordi: His engineering acumen gives him enough knowledge to improvise when Data's rescue plan gets thrown an unexpected curveball. His basic decency is such that, despite Serova displaying no sympathetic traits whatever, he still feels guilt when she is driven to rash action.


THOUGHTS

Force of Nature is TNG's environmentalist episode. It's the one in which warp drive turns out to be damaging the fabric of the universe. I'd love to say that this idea has potential. The truth is, it was a lousy idea from the start. With warp drive so integral a part of the Star Trek franchise, it was inevitable that the limits put on warp travel in this episode would never be enforceable across multiple series. The only possible result was what happened: The limit was paid lip service to a very few times before being utterly ignored thereafter.

Which... Fair enough. It's an episode that exists entirely in isolation, because it cannot affect the wider franchise. Fine. After all, Ethics paralyzed Worf, ended with us being told that he had a long, slow road ahead of him, and then saw him 100% recovered by the next episode with the incident never even mentioned again.  None of which prevented it from being a worthy episode in its own right. 

The biggest problem with Force of Nature has nothing to do with implications to the franchise... The biggest problem is that it's a bad idea that is badly executed.


SEROVA

A major miscalculation is the characterization of Serova, the angry Hekaran scientist. We are meant to see her as brilliant and driven, frustrated because no one will listen to her inconvenient truth. What we get... is a terrorist. She mines the corridor, deliberately disabling vessels in the same way that extreme environmental protesters sometimes spike trees to destroy loggers' equipment. She defends her actions as simply causing "inconvenience," brushing aside the point that the disabling of a ship on an emergency mission could result in death and disaster because "That didn't happen."

After she takes drastic action, deliberately opening a rift to prove that she's right, Geordi laments that she had to do this "to make (the Enterprise crew) listen." Uh, no. She was actually given a much fairer hearing than her conduct deserved. Data validated that her research had merit, and Picard made it clear that he would recommend a science team come out to do in-depth study. In short, despite her methods, she succeeded in getting a far better result than could reasonably have been hoped for. 

...But since Picard doesn't give in completely to her demands, instead wanting to investigate the situation, she decides to take an even more aggressive tact.  In so doing, she puts two ships' crews in mortal danger. Once again: Behaving not like a scientist, but like a terrorist. We are even told that the rift she deliberately creates has a tangible impact on her planet's environment - Meaning that in seeking to prove that she's "right," she ends up damaging the very thing she's trying to protect.

An irony that goes completely unobserved by the episode, which trudges tediously along through a contrived climax that mainly involves shaking the camera a lot while Patrick Stewart, Brent Spiner, and Levar Burton try to convey intensity while reciting Technobabble at us. There is one irony here, though, and that's...


THE PICARD SLEDGE-HAMMER

Just in case we haven't had enough, the episode ends with Picard declaring that he's apparently been creating damage all these years by exploring new worlds. In a dumb script that doesn't even seem to notice that Serova has damaged the world she meant to protect through her over-aggressive actions, Picard actually states that he has damaged "the thing I held most dear." It's a moment made for nausea and eye-rolls, given an extra-gooey button as Geordi assures Picard that "We're going to make it better."

As the episode goes to credits, I am left to ponder. Not on the shallow and obvious environmental message. No, I'm left to wonder about something far grimmer: Whether Season Seven might just end up being worse than Season One was. Those early episodes may have been pathetically bad... but at least they had energy, a quality sorely lacking in most of these late-series offerings.


Overall Rating: 1/10.

Previous Episode: Attached
Next Episode: Inheritance


Search Amazon.com for Star Trek: The Next Generation



To receive new review updates, follow me:

On Twitter:

On Threads:

1 comment:

  1. I have to say even by the exceptional standards of this site, this review is superb- the premise is so staggeringly misconceived one wonders what the series writing staff were thinking.

    The sole reason to grade this above 1 is the scene between Picard and the Ferengi commander. This may sound odd but I like the idea that the Federation and Ferengi, whilst still at odds on many issues, can at least have a realistic conversation with a better understanding of each others' motivation. Nevertheless, I recognise I am clutching at straws.

    I am also intrigued by the comparison between season seven and one called out in the last paragraph - I think three of the upcoming episodes are substantially better than anything Season 1 came up with (no Spoilers) - nevertheless, I agree there's a sense the series is at this point running on 'fumes' and that episodes which in prior seasons might be mediocre are poorly and perfunctorily executed to the extent they become clunkers.....

    Great stuff, as I say - can't wait to read more!

    ReplyDelete