The Enterprise is transporting quarrelsome delegates from two warring species, the dog-like Anticans and the reptilian Selay, both of whom have applied for entry into the Federation. Their destination is a peace conference on the planet Parliament. En route, however, the ship encounters a mysterious cloud-like energy formation. Picard orders a brief detour to investigate... and a mysterious energy surge promptly puts Worf in Sickbay.
The surge was caused by an energy creature, which passes from Worf to Dr. Crusher to the Enterprise computers, where it begins sabotaging the ship. The crew slowly work out the nature of the threat... but by the time they realize that the ship has been invaded by an energy being capable of taking over crew members, Picard himself has succumbed!
CHARACTERS
Capt. Picard: Patrick Stewart does particularly well with the last third or so of the episode, playing the possessed Picard. He slows down his line deliveries, and delivers every line with a calm serenity that is at odds with the (somewhat exaggeratedly) grumpy demeanor that "normal Picard" exhibits. Without actually doing anything specifically threatening, his scenes carry a wonderful eerie quality that lifts the episode itself considerably.
Riker: For purposes of this episode only, Riker becomes a bit of a wimp. The previous five episodes have firmly established that Riker will challenge the captain and even stand up to his authority when he deems it necessary. Not only suspecting, but knowing that the captain has been possessed by an alien intelligence... Riker suddenly can't do anything about it. Riiight...
Dr. Crusher: Even more hilariously implausible than Riker's inaction is Crusher's. Picard confirms to Crusher's face that he is possessed. What does the good doctor do? Does she instantly relieve him of command? Does she leave the room, call for help, then come back to relieve him of command? No, she simply says that "the more frightens me," and then does nothing. She also fails to report to anyone suddenly finding herself on the bridge, with a gap in her memory, until well after it becomes clear that there is a problem. She receives no reprimand of any kind for waiting to speak up; no one even mentions that doing so might have saved a fair bit of trouble. Ah, well. At least she's pretty.
Data: Gets some of the more entertaining material in the episode, when an offhand remark by Picard about wondering what Sherlock Holmes would make of this puzzle results in Data smoking a pipe and speaking in Holmesian dialogue. Most amusing is when, in mid-pompous Holmes, he suddenly gives RIker a sidelong glance and adds, "Sir."
IT'S TIME FOR... BRATS IN SPAAACE!
Wesley's specialness allows him to diagnose the nature of the problem with the engines when the engineer is unable to do so. When the engineer sends Wesley away to class, he whines about how much better he understands these problems than the actual crew members do. Couldn't the energy creature have beamed out in Wesley instead of what it ends up doing? Then the ship could leave Wesley the Wonderful there to swim around as an energy beam forever, and never blight the television screen again.
LET'S PLAY... ZAP THE REDSHIRT!
The first redshirt death in Next Generation. All right, technically he's a goldshirt, but that doesn't quite have the same ring to it. After Wesley has, with extreme brilliance and perceptiveness, pointed out to the plodding Engineer Singh the nature of the problem with the engines, Singh sends Wesley away. He then begins examining the problem, only to get zapped by the energy being. Instead of taking over his body, it kills him... for reasons never explained, save that it was apparently accidental. I guess as dangerous as it is to be a random crew member with a brief speaking part in Trek, it's doubly dangerous to be non-white with a brief speaking part.
THOUGHTS
After the very high quality of Where No One Has Gone Before, I felt reassured that there at least would be a few good episodes in Season One of TNG. Sadly, this is not one of them.
Which is not to say it's howlingly inept, in the manner of Code of Honor or The Last Outpost. This is a competently-executed episode. The early part establishes a mystery, which deepens over the course of the episode, before being resolved at the end. The visual effects for the energy cloud are dated, but still suitably eye-catching, even if they don't equal the gorgeous effects representing the end of the universe in Where No One Has Gone Before. It's all perfectly competent.
Unfortunately, it's also quite boring.
Things pick up a bit once Picard gets possessed. However, the first 30 minutes or so of this episode move very, very slowly. The subplot with the alien delegates goes nowhere, and when they start lurking in the (unusually dark) corridors to ambush each other, I wondered why anyone on the ship would really mind the prospect of them killing each other off. Both races come across as uncouth, arrogant, and violent.
The main plot sees a return to the pacing problems that have plagued this series from the get-go, with no real sense of building tension. Characters are dumbed down specifically so that the problem can't be spotted early on. Troi is always useless, sure... But she doesn't sense that the doctor, standing two feet away from her and behaving very strangely, has been suddenly taken over by an alien being? Either her empathic abilities have a point, or they don't. If they don't, then just drop them already.
Tension only starts to build once Picard is taken over - a point that should have been reached much sooner, and held longer. Even then, any suspense is promptly diffused when technobabbling the techno-gizmo and feeding it through the transporter miraculously resolves all problems.
Oh, and there's a comedy "tag" involving a delegate being killed and prepared as a meal. As Beavis and Butthead would say: Heh heh heh.
Rating: 4/10.
Previous Episode: Where No One Has Gone Before
Next Episode: Justice
Search Amazon.com for Star Trek: The Next Generation
Review Index
To receive new review updates, follow me:
On Twitter:
On Threads:
I might give the episode 5/10 for the feud between the Anticans and the Selay, and the scene where they attack Riker by mistake: "Sorry, wrong species."
ReplyDeleteBTW, the Anticans were supposed to be mongoose-like, and the Selay were supposed to be cobra-like, alluding to the well-known fights between cobras and mongooses.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vdg9gkmWsEA
I lived in a TV-free household for a couple of decades, so although I was a serious TOS fan from the age of eleven, until a month ago, TOS was the only Star Trek I'd ever seen.
ReplyDeleteAt that point, I started to watch TNG. People had warned me that the first season wasn't very good, so I persevered through an unexpectedly racist episode, a wildly sexist episode, and a really stupid episode. Then I watched "Lonely Among Us," and I was SCREAMING at the screen. Hoo, boy.
Watching this horrible episode, I kept wishing for Kirk, Spock and McCoy. When the Selay guys beam aboard and ask if their quarters are anywhere near their enemies, Riker says they’re about 100 meters apart, and Picard asks anxiously if that’s okay. The head Selay says it’s not okay and starts giving orders, which Riker and Picard accommodate.
Say what? I kept imagining Jim Kirk there, telling the head Selay that they don’t give orders on HIS ship, and since their goal is to make peace, then can damn well begin by acting like civilized beings and going quietly to their assigned quarters.
Then later on, Picard ADMITS to the ship’s doctor that he’s been taken over by an alien creature. The first officer and doctor try to do something about this, but Picard tells them to go away and stop bothering him, and they run away with their tails between their legs.
Say WHAT? If Kirk had admitted to Spock and McCoy that he was possessed by an alien creature, first they’d have tried to talk to it. But if that didn’t work, Spock would have neck-pinched him or McCoy would have hypoed him unconscious. I couldn’t believe that Riker and Crusher just kinda shrugged and told each other that there was nothing they could do. How the hell are these people going to SURVIVE in a dangerous galaxy?
Where’s my confident, in-charge captain? Where’s my knows-everything, ready-for-anything Vulcan? Where’s my crusty, fearless doctor?
*sigh*
Friends tell me that TNG is going to get MUCH better. I’m amazed it survived long enough to do so.
I really WAS trying not to expect the new guys to be like the old ones. But when the new ones are stupid and ineffectual, it's a lot harder to maintain that position.
I can't believe Dorothy Fontana -- who wrote a lot of TOS episodes, including the highly wonderful "Journey to Babel" -- wrote THIS mess. Dorothy, were you sick? On drugs? Trying to show Roddenberry what an ass he was being with his rules for the new show? What? I KNOW you can do better than this!
*sigh* I think I need an episode or two of TOS as a palate-cleanser before I can go on to the next TNG episode.
Cory: Sadly, the next episode is even worse. There are some better ones in the mid-season... But yes, Season One is pretty awful. In retrospect, it's hard to believe I was so generous as to award this a "4" at the time - I must have been grading on a curve, adjusting for it not being quite as bad as some of the ones surrounding it!
ReplyDelete